I've run into a similar situation.
Bought a house, wanted Verizon FIOS, but oops, the only fiber service allowed in my area is ATT.
Better service, allegedly, than the Comcast plan I had in my apt, and $50 less a month to boot, but due to the legalized/regulated monopoly, no dice for the service I've had before and would prefer to have now.
I typically lean conservative but more and more I feel I agree with Libertarians. I'd really rather the government just left me the hell alone, because I know that I'm a better judge of whats good for me than they are, and you are a better judge of what's good for you, which isn't any of my concern.